Scholarly Comments on Academic Economics

Adam Smith and the Invisible Hand: From Metaphor to Myth


Read this article

Access statistics
39,596 article downloads
5,899 complete issue downloads
Total: 45,495


Adam Smith and the ‘invisible hand’ are nearly synonymous in modern economic thinking. Adam Smith is strongly associated with the invisible hand, understood as a general rule that people in realising their self-interests unintentionally benefit the public good. The attribution to Smith is challengeable. Adam Smith’s use of the metaphor was much more modest; it was re-invented in the 1930s and 1940s onwards to bolster mathematical treatments of capitalism (Samuelson, Friedman) and to support innovative analysis by associating the metaphor with ‘spontaneous order’ (Hayek). The effect has been to ignore insightful explanations about how markets function as a process in favour of semi-mystical beliefs in imagined outcomes, wrapped in an isolated 18th-century literary metaphor, which does not explain anything.

Comment on this article by Daniel B. Klein: In Adam Smith’s Invisible Hands: Comment on Gavin Kennedy (EJW, May 2009).