Scholarly Comments on Academic Economics

Argentina’s Problems Went Far Beyond the Absence of a Strict Currency Board: Comment on Schuler


Download this article

4,945 article downloads
8,147 complete issue downloads
Total: 13,092


KURT SCHULER ARGUES MOST ECONOMISTS (MYSELF INCLUDED) failed to get the facts right. Schuler writes, “economists whose work in other areas I admire failed to do the research necessary for understanding Argentina’s situation accurately. As a result their analysis was faulty” (Schuler 2005, 235). This mischaracterization of Argentina’s economic situation led them to prescribe inappropriate policies, not the least recommending that Argentina end its tight link to the dollar.

This article is a response to Ignorance and Influence: U.S. Economists on Argentina’s Depression of 1998–2002 by Kurt Schuler (EJW, August 2005).