Scholarly Comments on Academic Economics

Decline in Critical Commentary, 1963–2004

by , , and
edited by

Read this article

Access statistics
5,474 article downloads
7,963 complete issue downloads
Total: 13,437


Over the past four decades, top economics journals have virtually eliminated critical commentary (comments, replies, rejoinders, and the like). This article shows the data and discusses these steep declines in critical commentary. To the extent that critical commentary is beneficial to scientific inquiry, editorial opposition to critical commentary is detrimental to the advancement of economic knowledge.