Scholarly Comments on Academic Economics

Replications in Economics: A Progress Report

by , , and

Read this article

Access statistics
4,019 article downloads
3,735 complete issue downloads
Total: 7,754

Abstract

We report on various aspects of replication research in economics. Our report includes (i) a brief history of data sharing and replication; (ii) the results of a survey administered to the editors of all 333 economics journals listed in Web of Science; (iii) an analysis of 162 replication studies that have been published in peer-reviewed economics journals from 1977–2014; (iv) a discussion of the future of replication research in economics; and (v) observations on how replications can be better integrated into research efforts to address problems associated with publication bias and other Type I error phenomena. This paper is part of an ongoing project which includes the website replicationnetwork.com, which provides additional, regularly updated information on replications in economics.

Podcast related to this article: W. Robert Reed on Replication in Economics (EJW Audio, May 2015).